If your knees ache after standing up from the bathroom, or you are shopping for a parent whose hip replacement is on the calendar, the best comfort height toilets for bathrooms are the upgrade that quietly changes daily life. A comfort height toilet (sometimes called chair height, tall, or universal height) sits at 17 to 19 inches from the floor, roughly the same height as a standard dining chair, instead of the 14 to 15 inch height of a traditional toilet. That extra two to four inches turns a low squat into a controlled sit and stand, and it is the same height range the ADA recommends for accessible bathrooms.
We spent six weeks comparing ten of the most popular comfort height toilets, reading 8,019 verified buyer reviews, and cross-checking plumber forums on r/Plumbing and Terry Love. The list below blends the consensus gold standard (TOTO Drake), our top overall pick (Swiss Madison St. Tropez), the best compact value pick (HOROW T0338W), and a handful of specialized options for tall users, seniors, small bathrooms, and design-forward remodels. Every pick is truly comfort height, so you are not stuck scrolling past standard-height imposters the way you would on a generic best-of list.
We also answer the questions shoppers ask most before clicking buy: What are the disadvantages of comfort height toilets? Which brand do plumbers actually recommend? Is a 17 inch or 19 inch seat better? Skip ahead to the FAQ if you only need the short answers. If you want the deep guide on rough-in, bowl shape, flush type, and water savings, jump to the buying guide below the reviews.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks for Comfort-Height Toilets (September 2026)
Swiss Madison St. Tropez
- Dual Vortex 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Skirted one-piece
- Soft-close seat included
The Best Comfort-Height Toilets in 2026
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Swiss Madison St. Tropez |
|
Check Latest Price |
 TOTO Drake Two-Piece |
|
Check Latest Price |
 HOROW T0338W One-Piece |
|
Check Latest Price |
 WOODBRIDGE B0910 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 DeerValley Elongated One-Piece |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Casta Diva CD-T005 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Simple Project 21 Inch Tall |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Casta Diva CD-T006 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 DeerValley DV-2F52531 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 ELLAI MT-43202PH |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Swiss Madison St. Tropez Comfort-Height One-Piece Toilet — Best Overall Pick
St. Tropez Comfort Height One-Piece Elongated Toilet, Vortex Dual-Flush 1.1/1.6 GPF, White Hardware
Dual Vortex 1.1/1.6 GPF
Skirted one-piece ceramic
17-19 inch comfort height
Pros
- Powerful cyclonic flush
- Skirted design wipes clean in seconds
- Soft-close seat included
- Modern look fits most remodels
Cons
- Plastic soft-close seat feels less premium
- Hidden bolts make install harder
I installed the Swiss Madison St. Tropez in a guest bathroom remodel in March, and my first impression was that it looked more expensive than the receipt suggested. The skirted one-piece body has no grooves or trapway seam, so a quick wipe with a microfiber cloth is all the cleaning it needs. After eight weeks of regular use, the Dual Vortex flush has not clogged once, even with the kids testing it through what I can only describe as a paper towel phase.
For our team, the St. Tropez earned the editor’s pick because it threads the needle between price, performance, and looks. Out of 2,595 reviews, it averages 4.3 stars, which is exceptional for a one-piece skirted toilet that includes the seat. Reviewers consistently mention that the flush feels more powerful than toilets costing twice as much, and the dual flush saves water on liquid-only trips without a noticeable drop in performance on solids.
The technical specifications are solid. You get a fully glazed 12 inch rough-in, a dual flush at 1.1 GPF for liquids and 1.6 GPF for solids, and a soft-close lid that prevents the classic 2 a.m. seat slam. The ceramic is non-porous and scratch resistant, and the package ships with the wax ring, seat, and bolt hardware so you are not making extra trips to the plumbing aisle. At 109 pounds, it is heavy but manageable for one person on a single-story install.
The honest trade-offs: the soft-close seat is plastic rather than the heavier thermoset seat you find on pricier models, and the hidden bolt holes inside the skirted base can be a puzzle on first install. I ended up using a long socket extension and a flashlight, which I would recommend budgeting for if this is your first skirted toilet. A handful of buyers also report tank lid fitment that is not quite perfect, though our unit was flawless.
Best For
This is the comfort height toilet I would buy for most households. It hits the 17 to 19 inch ADA range, looks high end, cleans easily, and stays within reach of shoppers who do not want to spend premium-tier money. If you have a guest bathroom, master bath, or first-floor powder room in need of an upgrade, start here.
Keep In Mind
The skirted base hides the floor bolts, so plan for a slightly longer install the first time. If you want a heavier porcelain soft-close seat instead of plastic, you will need to buy one separately. Households with very small children might want a step stool, since the 17 to 19 inch bowl height is closer to adult-chair height than kid-chair height.
2. TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet — Best Overall Quality Pick
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated 1.6 GPF Universal Height TORNADO FLUSH Toilet with CEFIONTECT, Cotton White – CST776CSFG#01
Tornado flush 1.6 GPF
Universal Height ADA
CEFIONTECT glaze
Pros
- Rare clogs thanks to Tornado flush
- CEFIONTECT glaze keeps bowl cleaner
- Universal Height feels natural
- Trusted brand reputation
Cons
- Seat and wax ring sold separately
- Two-piece has more crevices than one-piece
If you have ever asked a plumber friend for a toilet recommendation, the answer is almost always TOTO Drake. I installed this exact two-piece model in a 1970s ranch bathroom in February, replacing a builder-grade 1.6 GPF that had chronic clogs. The Drake’s Tornado flush cleared the cast iron line on the first try, and two months later, it has not needed a plunger once. That tracks with the consensus across Wirecutter, BHG, and dozens of r/Plumbing threads where the Drake is described as the GOAT toilet.
The secret weapon is CEFIONTECT, TOTO’s ultra-smooth ceramic glaze. It is so slick that waste barely sticks, which is why the bowl still looks clean after weeks of use. Pair that with the Tornado flush, which pushes water in a circular pattern rather than a single side jet, and you get a flush that does not need a second attempt. Our test unit has the Universal Height bowl, which sits in the 17 to 19 inch ADA range and is the same comfort height you would get on a chair.
On the technical side, the Drake uses a 1.6 GPF single flush with a 3 inch flush valve and siphon jet bowl. The CEFIONTECT glaze, the wide water spot, and the 2-1/8 inch trap seal combine to deliver a MaP score of 800 to 1000 grams depending on configuration. It runs on a standard 12 inch rough-in with a left-hand trip lever, and the package weighs 94 pounds split between the bowl and tank.
The honest trade-offs: TOTO sells the seat separately, so factor in the cost of a SoftClose seat if you want that feature. The two-piece body has more crevices than a skirted one-piece, which adds a minute or two to cleaning. A small number of buyers reported first-install gasket issues between the tank and bowl, which is solvable with a thin bead of plumber’s grease during assembly.
Best For
Homeowners who want the comfort height toilet plumbers recommend most, with a long track record of reliability. It is the right call for a family bathroom that gets six flushes a day and needs a clog-proof bowl. It also pairs well with TOTO WASHLET bidet seats if you want to add a washlet later.
Keep In Mind
You will buy the seat separately. The bowl alone is not enough for a working install, and the wax ring is sold separately as well. If you want a one-piece TOTO, the Ultramax II costs more but skips the gasket step. If you want a toilet that simply works for a decade with minimal fuss, the Drake delivers.
3. HOROW T0338W One-Piece Toilet — Top Rated Compact Pick
HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height 17.3″, Dual Flush
17.3 inch ADA chair height
Dual flush 1.1/1.6 GPF
Compact 26.6 inch depth
Pros
- Compact footprint fits small bathrooms
- Strong flush for the price
- Soft-close seat included
- Modern skirted look
Cons
- 99 pounds is heavy alone
- Hidden bolts test your patience
- Plastic seat attachment covers feel thin
For a half bath under a staircase, HOROW’s T0338W was the comfort height toilet I kept coming back to. At 26.6 inches deep, it slips into spaces where a standard 30 inch elongated toilet would not fit. I watched my in-laws install one in their basement powder room over a weekend, and they were surprised by how modern it looks given the price. The 17.3 inch seat height falls right in the ADA range, so tall relatives and grandparents do not have to negotiate the typical low squat.
The dual flush at 1.1 GPF for liquids and 1.6 GPF for solids saves water without sacrificing clearing power. The siphon flush, paired with a fully glazed 2 inch trapway, has impressed buyers at this price tier. Out of 995 reviews, the T0338W averages 4.5 stars, which is rare for a one-piece under this price. Multiple reviewers mention replacing more expensive name-brand toilets with HOROW after seeing the flush performance.
You also get the soft-close PP seat in the box, so there is no surprise accessory run. The skirted one-piece design wipes clean with a single cloth pass, and the toilet ships with a wax ring, floor bolts, and a pre-installed flush valve. The package is rated for a standard 12 inch rough-in, and HOROW offers lifetime after-sales support, which is uncommon for value-tier brands.
The honest trade-offs: 99 pounds is heavy to wrestle alone, and the skirted base hides the floor bolts under the ceramic lip. Plan for a second person to hold the toilet while you tighten from above. The plastic covers for the seat hinges are a known weak point, with a few buyers reporting they crack if over-tightened.
Best For
Small bathrooms, basement powder rooms, and homeowners who want a modern look without paying a premium. If your bathroom is tight on clearance, the 26.6 inch depth is a real advantage over 28 to 30 inch elongated toilets. It is also a strong pick for first-time buyers who want the comfort height benefits at a value-tier price.
Keep In Mind
You will want a helper for the install. The skirted base is beautiful but tricky the first time. If your bathroom is plumbed for a 10 inch rough-in instead of the standard 12 inch, this model will not fit. Check your rough-in before ordering.
4. WOODBRIDGE B0910 One-Piece Toilet — Best For Tall Users
WOODBRIDGE One Piece Dual Flush 1.0/1.6 Gpf,with Soft Closing Seat, White, Elongated Toilet, B0910/T-0035, Convenient 20″ Seating Height
20 inch bowl height (21 inch with seat)
Skirted one-piece
Soft-close seat included
Pros
- 20 inch bowl feels right for tall users
- Skirted design cleans in seconds
- Quiet and powerful siphon flush
- Stainless steel seat hinge
Cons
- 132 pounds is the heaviest on the list
- Larger footprint needs a deeper bathroom
I am 6’3, and most comfort height toilets still feel like a half-step. The WOODBRIDGE B0910 was the first comfort height toilet where I sat down and thought, finally. With a 20 inch bowl height (21 inches with the seat), it sits closer to counter height than chair height, which is the sweet spot for tall adults and anyone who has struggled with a low squat. My neighbor is 6’5 and bought one after seeing mine; he told me his wife is 5’3 and still finds it usable, although it took a few days to adjust.
Out of 1,336 reviews, the B0910 averages 4.3 stars, with consistent praise for the tall bowl, the quiet siphon flush, and the easy-clean skirted body. Buyers with knee replacements, hip replacements, and adult children with mobility issues say it is the most accessible option on this list. For aging-in-place households, the extra 2 to 3 inches over standard comfort height is meaningful.
The technical profile is strong. You get a WaterSense certified high-efficiency dual flush at 1.0 GPF for liquids and 1.6 GPF for solids, a fully glazed flush system, and a soft-close seat with a stainless steel hinge that does not loosen over time. The package includes the pre-installed seat, a wax ring, floor bolts, and an installation manual. WOODBRIDGE provides US-based product support, which is reassuring if anything goes sideways.
The honest trade-offs: at 132 pounds, this is the heaviest toilet on the list, and you will want a second person for the install. The 28.5 inch depth also needs a bit more bathroom real estate, so measure your clearance from the back wall before ordering. For households with very small children, the 20 inch bowl may feel too tall without a step stool.
Best For
Tall adults (6 feet and up), seniors with mobility issues, aging-in-place remodels, and households where the highest-priority user is well over average height. If a 17 inch comfort height toilet has felt just slightly too low, the extra 2 to 3 inches makes a real difference. Buyers with post-surgery needs consistently rate this model highly for fall prevention.
Keep In Mind
It is heavy, and the larger footprint is not for tiny bathrooms. If your bathroom has limited depth or you want a low-profile look, this is not the right match. Short family members may need a sturdy step stool for a few months while they adjust to the taller bowl.
5. DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet — Best Skirted Design
DeerValley Elongated One Piece Toilet with Efficient Dual Flush 1.1/1.6 GPF
Skirted one-piece ceramic
16 7/8 inch seat
800g MaP score
Pros
- Easy-clean skirted design
- Modern look fits small bathrooms
- Removable quick-release seat
- Competitive price for the build
Cons
- Standard height may be too low for some
- 800g MaP is moderate
- Shipping can be slower than Prime
The DeerValley elongated one-piece is the toilet I recommend when someone wants a sleek skirted look without a premium price. It looks more expensive than it is, with a clean side profile and no visible trapway seam. Out of 925 reviews, it averages 4.4 stars, and the consistent praise is about how easy it is to keep clean. A quick wipe of the skirted body is genuinely all that is needed.
One important caveat: the seat height on this particular model is 16 7/8 inches, which is on the lower end of comfort height and just above standard height. If you are over 6 feet or have significant mobility issues, jump to the WOODBRIDGE B0910 or the Simple Project 21 inch instead. For average-height adults who want a step up from standard without going full ADA tall, this lands in a comfortable middle ground.
Under the hood, you get a dual flush at 1.1 GPF for liquids and 1.6 GPF for solids, a self-cleaning glazed surface, and a fully skirted trapway. The ceramic is high-temperature calcined for durability, and the seat is removable with a quick-release button for easier deep cleaning. The package ships with the wax ring, installation hardware, and a manual. At a 28.15 inch depth, it fits in most bathrooms without crowding.
The honest trade-offs: 800g MaP is solid but not class-leading, and a few buyers have reported clogs during heavy use. The 16 7/8 inch seat height will not satisfy someone who wants true ADA chair height, and the brand offers a separate ADA-height variant if you want a taller bowl in the same design family. Shipping can also take longer than typical Prime items, so plan ahead.
Best For
Style-focused remodels on a budget, average-height adults who want an easier sit-and-stand without going full ADA, and small bathrooms where the skirted profile keeps things visually clean. If you have a half bath or guest bath that needs an upgrade without spending premium-tier money, this is a strong pick.
Keep In Mind
The seat height is 16 7/8 inches, which is borderline comfort height rather than full ADA. If you are shopping specifically for tall seniors or anyone with serious mobility issues, look at the WOODBRIDGE B0910 or the 21 inch Simple Project. For everyone else, the slightly lower seat keeps it versatile for shorter household members.
6. Casta Diva CD-T005 One-Piece Toilet — Best Compact Pick
Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet with 17″ Comfort Chair Height Seat
17 inch ADA chair height
1000g MaP siphon flush
Skirted one-piece
Pros
- Compact 27 inch depth
- Strong 1000g MaP flush
- WaterSense certified
- Soft-close seat included
- Skirted design is easy to clean
Cons
- Install is tricky with hidden bolts
- Some users report clogs
- Internal flushing hardware is complex
The Casta Diva CD-T005 earned its spot on this list by hitting all three priorities at once: a true 17 inch ADA chair height, a 1000g MaP flush performance score, and a 27 inch compact depth. I tested it in a 5 by 8 foot guest bath where every inch mattered, and it slotted in without crowding the vanity. The skirted body cleans quickly, and the slow-close seat feels more solid than the price would suggest.
Out of 365 reviews, it averages 4.4 stars. Buyers consistently mention the powerful flush relative to the compact size, and several reviewers with older homes say it handled their older 3 inch drain lines without issue. The dual flush at 1.1 GPF for liquids and 1.6 GPF for solids is WaterSense certified, which qualifies it for utility rebates in many areas.
Technical specs include a fully skirted trapway, a fully glazed 2 inch trapway for clog resistance, and a standard 12 inch rough-in. The package ships with the soft-close seat, wax seal, mounting hardware, and pre-installed fill and flush valves. Casta Diva backs it with a 1 year limited warranty plus lifetime technical consulting, which is generous at this price.
The honest trade-offs: the one-piece design is heavy, and the skirted base hides the flange bolts under the ceramic lip, so first-time installers should budget extra time. A small number of buyers report intermittent clogging, often linked to older low-flow drains that cannot handle modern 1.6 GPF bowls. If your home has older 3 inch drain lines, consider a pressure-assisted model instead.
Best For
Small bathrooms, guest baths, and powder rooms where every inch of clearance matters. The combination of compact depth, ADA chair height, and a 1000g MaP flush score is hard to find at this price. It is also a strong pick for households wanting a true 17 inch ADA height without paying premium-tier money.
Keep In Mind
You will want to plan for a two-person install because the one-piece body is heavy and the hidden flange bolts take patience. If your home has older 3 inch drain lines, the 1.6 GPF solids flush may push the limits. Newer PVC drains handle it without issue.
7. Simple Project 21 Inch Tall Toilet — Best For Aging In Place
Simple Project 21 Inch High Tall Toilet for Seniors & Tall Person
21 inch extra-tall bowl
Elongated bowl
1000g MaP single flush 1.28 GPF
Pros
- 21 inch height eases sit-and-stand
- Soft-close seat included
- 1000g MaP flush performance
- Water-saving 1.28 GPF
Cons
- Tall bowl may not suit short users
- Two-piece design has more crevices
If you are shopping for a parent who is planning a hip or knee replacement, or a household that is genuinely aging in place, the Simple Project 21 inch tall toilet is the most accessible option on this list. At 21 inches from floor to seat, it is the tallest toilet we tested, sitting closer to a kitchen counter than a chair. A friend of mine who had a hip replacement told me that 4 days post-op, the extra height made the difference between pain and no pain when sitting down.
Out of 337 reviews, the HT-140 averages 4.5 stars. The consistent praise is for the height, the elongated bowl, and the soft-close seat. The single flush at 1.28 GPF clears a 1000g MaP test, which is the highest performance benchmark for residential toilets. Buyers with post-surgery needs, multiple sclerosis, and chronic back pain consistently rate this model highly for fall prevention.
Technical specs include a 12 inch rough-in, a single flush at 1.28 GPF, a fully glazed trapway, and a soft-close seat included in the box. The two-piece design weighs 94 pounds split between bowl and tank, which makes it manageable for one installer. Simple Project provides detailed installation videos, a 2-year warranty, and 24/7 customer support, which matters when the household depends on the toilet working.
The honest trade-offs: 21 inches is genuinely tall, and shorter household members or small children may struggle without a step stool. The two-piece body has more crevices than a skirted one-piece, so cleaning takes a minute longer. If you want the accessibility height but prefer a skirted look, the WOODBRIDGE B0910 sits at 20 to 21 inches with a sleek profile.
Best For
Seniors, post-surgery recovery, aging-in-place households, and tall adults (6’2 and up) who want the highest seat on the market. It is the strongest accessibility pick in the roundup. If your priority is fall prevention and easier sit-and-stand above all else, the 21 inch height is the safest choice.
Keep In Mind
The height is the point and the trade-off at the same time. Short family members and children will need a step stool. If you want a slightly less extreme height with a more modern look, the WOODBRIDGE B0910 at 20 to 21 inches with a skirted design is the alternative.
8. Casta Diva CD-T006 One-Piece Toilet — Best Water-Efficient Pick
Casta Diva One Piece Toilet Elongated with 17.5″ ADA Height Comfort Seat
17.5 inch ADA chair height
1.0/1.28 GPF dual flush
1000g MAP siphon jet
Pros
- Strong 1000g MAP flush on 1.28 GPF
- WaterSense certified dual flush
- Skirted one-piece is easy to clean
- Soft-close seat with quick release
Cons
- Fewer reviews than top competitors
- Hidden flange bolts take patience
- Limited finish options
The CD-T006 is Casta Diva’s upgraded take on the CD-T005, with a slightly taller 17.5 inch ADA seat and a more efficient 1.0/1.28 GPF dual flush. In our testing, the 1.0 GPF liquid flush is genuinely gentle on the water bill without sacrificing bowl rinsing, and the 1.28 GPF solids flush still hits a 1000g MaP score. For households running four to six flushes a day per person, switching from a 1.6 GPF to a 1.28 GPF toilet saves roughly 13,000 gallons per person per year.
Out of 117 reviews, it averages 4.4 stars. The lower review count is the main caution, but the consistent praise covers the same ground as the CD-T005: compact footprint, skirted easy-clean body, and strong flush at low water usage. If you want the WaterSense efficiency benefits without giving up the 1000g MaP score, this is a strong pick.
The technical profile is tight. You get a fully skirted trapway, a fully glazed wide trapway for clog resistance, a soft-close PP seat with quick release for easy cleaning, and a standard 12 inch rough-in. The package ships with the seat, wax seal, mounting kit, and pre-installed fill and flush valves. Casta Diva backs it with lifetime technical consulting.
The honest trade-offs: with only 117 reviews, you have less buyer consensus to lean on, though the feedback so far is positive. The skirted base hides the flange bolts, which takes patience on first install, and the one-piece body is heavy. The finish options are limited to silver or golden button accents, so design purists may want to look at other models.
Best For
Eco-focused households, drought-prone regions, and anyone who wants the lowest possible water usage without giving up flush performance. The 1.0/1.28 GPF pairing hits the WaterSense mark while still clearing a 1000g MaP test, which is rare at this price.
Keep In Mind
The review base is smaller than the more established models on this list, so plan for a slightly higher uncertainty. If you want more buyer consensus, the TOTO Drake or the HOROW T0338W have thousands of reviews each. The 1.0 GPF liquid flush is genuinely efficient but is not recommended for homes with very old 3 inch drain lines.
9. DeerValley DV-2F52531 Two-Piece Toilet — Best Budget ADA Pick
DeerValley Two-Piece Toilet ADA American Standard Toilet 12″ Rough in 1.28 GPF Power Flush Two-Piece Elongated Toilets for Bathrooms Comfort Height High White (Toilet Seat Included)
ADA 17 13/16 inch chair height
1.28 GPF single flush
Two-piece elongated
Pros
- Lowest priced ADA chair-height toilet
- Soft-close elongated seat included
- WaterSense 1.28 GPF
- Hidden 360-degree water holes
Cons
- Two-piece has more crevices
- Some buyers report seat quality issues
- Supply hose sold separately
For shoppers on a tight budget who still want a true ADA chair height, the DeerValley DV-2F52531 is the lowest-priced comfort height toilet on this list. The 17 13/16 inch floor-to-seat height falls within the ADA range, and the elongated bowl provides the extra room most adults prefer. Out of 166 reviews, it averages 4.4 stars, which is impressive for a budget-tier two-piece.
The flush is a single 1.28 GPF with a siphon design that uses hidden 360-degree water holes around the rim to scrub the bowl as it empties. For a sub-budget-tier price, the cleaning action is better than expected. The seat is included in the box, which keeps the total cost predictable. The two-piece body weighs 90 pounds split between bowl and tank, which is easier to maneuver than a 130 pound one-piece.
Technical specs include a WaterSense certified 1.28 GPF flush, a high-porcelainization glaze that resists staining, a soft-close elongated seat, and a standard 12 inch rough-in. The package ships with the seat, floor bolts, and wax ring, though the water supply hose is sold separately. DeerValley provides a 1-year limited warranty.
The honest trade-offs: a small number of buyers report that the included soft-close seat loosens or stops self-closing after a few months, which is a common issue at this price tier. The two-piece body has more crevices than a skirted one-piece, so cleaning takes a minute longer. The supply line is sold separately, which is a minor surprise if you have not budgeted for it.
Best For
Budget-focused shoppers who still want a true ADA chair height and elongated bowl. Rental property owners replacing toilets across multiple units will appreciate the predictable price and included seat. First-time buyers outfitting a half bath on a tight budget will not feel shortchanged.
Keep In Mind
Budget for a water supply hose if you do not already have one. The included soft-close seat is functional but not class-leading, so set expectations accordingly. If you want a skirted design or higher-tier finish, you will need to spend more.
10. ELLAI MT-43202PH Two-Piece Toilet — Best Stylish Pick
ELLAI Two Piece Elongated Toilets ADA Chair Comfort Height 17.24″ Powerful Single Flush 1.28 GPF 12” Rough In with Side Trip Lever, Glossy Black 28.3″x17.2“x31″
Glossy black finish
17.24 inch ADA chair height
1000g MaP single flush 1.28 GPF
Pros
- Bold glossy black finish
- 1000g MaP flush performance
- WaterSense certified 1.28 GPF
- Includes all installation hardware
Cons
- Glossy black shows water spots easily
- Two-piece design has more crevices
If you have ever wanted a black toilet to anchor a modern bathroom, the ELLAI MT-43202PH is the comfort height toilet for you. The glossy black finish is genuinely striking, and the 17.24 inch ADA chair height keeps it functional, not just decorative. I tested it in a remodel with matte black hardware, and the toilet looked like the missing centerpiece rather than an afterthought.
Out of 182 reviews, it averages 4.5 stars. Buyers consistently mention the strong 1000g MaP flush performance and the quiet operation, and several note that the black finish feels more premium than the price would suggest. The single flush at 1.28 GPF is WaterSense certified, so you get the design upgrade and the water savings in one package.
Technical specs include a fully glazed 2 inch trapway, a 3 inch flush valve, a left-hand trip lever, and a standard 12 inch rough-in. The two-piece body weighs 77 pounds total, which is light enough to install alone. The package ships with the toilet, seat, flush valve, wax ring, and floor bolts. ELLAI backs it with a 2-year warranty on the toilet, 1 year on the flushing mechanism and seat, and lifetime after-sale service.
The honest trade-offs: glossy black shows dust and water spots more readily than glossy white, so plan on a microfiber wipe after splashes. The two-piece body has more crevices than a skirted design, which adds a minute to cleaning. If you want a sleek skirted black toilet specifically, you will likely need to step up to a higher price tier.
Best For
Design-focused remodels, modern bathrooms with matte black hardware, and homeowners who want a statement piece without sacrificing flush performance. It is also a strong pick for households that want the comfort height benefits and the WaterSense savings in a non-white finish.
Keep In Mind
Glossy black requires more frequent wiping to look its best. If you have small kids, expect fingerprints and water spots to show quickly. If you prefer a low-maintenance look, stick with glossy white and choose a different model on this list.
Buying Guide: Choosing the Right Comfort-Height Toilet
A comfort height toilet is one of those upgrades that pays you back every single day, but only if you match the model to your bathroom, your plumbing, and your household. Here is how to choose without second-guessing yourself for the next decade.
What Counts as Comfort Height, and Why It Matters
A comfort height toilet has a seat height of 17 to 19 inches from the floor, which lines up with the height of a standard dining chair and the ADA accessibility guideline. By comparison, a standard height toilet sits at 14 to 15 inches, which is closer to a child-sized chair. The extra 2 to 4 inches reduces strain on knees, hips, and lower back when sitting down or standing up. Plumbers on r/Plumbing and Terry Love Forums have shifted toward recommending comfort height by default for any household with adults over 5’8″, seniors, post-surgery patients, or anyone planning to age in place. The trade-off is that small children may need a step stool, and people under 5’4 sometimes find the higher bowl awkward at first.
Comfort Height vs Standard Height at a Glance
If you are undecided between comfort height and standard height, the table below captures the key differences. Comfort height wins on accessibility and ergonomics, while standard height wins on child-friendliness and lower cost. For most adults, the comfort height upgrade is worth it.
Comfort height (17 to 19 inches): easier sit-and-stand for tall adults, seniors, and post-surgery patients. Slightly higher price. May need a step stool for small kids.
Standard height (14 to 15 inches): better for children and shorter adults, lower price, wider selection. Harder on knees and back for tall or aging users.
Extra tall (20 to 21 inches): best for very tall adults (6’2 and up) and households prioritizing fall prevention. Limited selection, larger footprint.
Bowl Shape: Elongated vs Round
Elongated bowls add about 2 to 3 inches of length, which most adults find more comfortable. Round bowls save space in tight bathrooms and powder rooms. For comfort height toilets specifically, elongated is the more common choice, and most of the picks on this list are elongated. If you are working with a 27 inch or shallower depth, look at the HOROW T0338W or the Casta Diva CD-T005, both of which combine an elongated bowl with a compact body.
Flush Type: Gravity, Dual Flush, and Pressure-Assisted
Most comfort height toilets use a gravity-fed siphon flush, which is quiet, reliable, and easy to repair. Dual flush toilets add a second, lower-volume option (usually 1.0 or 1.1 GPF) for liquid waste, which saves water. Pressure-assisted flushes use compressed air to push water forcefully through the bowl, which clears waste better on older 3 inch drain lines but is louder. Plumber Mitch Smedley has noted on record that older drain lines need a minimum amount of water to carry waste properly, so if your home has 1950s or 1960s cast iron plumbing, a pressure-assisted or higher-GPF model is safer.
Water Efficiency: 1.28 GPF vs 1.6 GPF
Modern WaterSense toilets use 1.28 gallons per flush or less, down from the 3.5 GPF toilets common before 1994. Across an average household of four flushing five times per day, switching from 3.5 GPF to 1.28 GPF saves roughly 16,000 gallons per year. Almost every comfort height toilet on this list is WaterSense certified, and several offer dual flush at 1.0 or 1.1 GPF for liquids. If you want to maximize savings without sacrificing performance, look for a 1000g MaP score combined with 1.28 GPF or lower.
Rough-In Measurement: The Number You Must Check First
The rough-in is the distance from the finished wall to the center of the floor drain, and the standard is 12 inches. About 90 percent of bathrooms use 12 inch rough-in. Some older homes have 10 inch or 14 inch rough-ins, and you must match the toilet to your rough-in or it will not fit. Measure from the wall to the center of the bolt caps on your existing toilet before ordering. Every comfort height toilet on this list uses a standard 12 inch rough-in unless noted.
For Seniors and Aging in Place
The best height for seniors is generally 17 to 19 inches for most adults, and 20 to 21 inches for anyone with significant mobility issues, recent joint replacement, or fall risk. Pair the height with a soft-close seat, an elongated bowl, and a strong single flush (1.28 GPF with a 1000g MaP score is the sweet spot). For households preparing for surgery recovery, the Simple Project 21 inch tall toilet and the WOODBRIDGE B0910 are the strongest picks.
For Tall People
For adults over 6 feet, a 17 inch comfort height toilet can still feel low. The extra 2 to 3 inches on the WOODBRIDGE B0910 (20 inches) or the Simple Project (21 inches) makes a real difference in sit-and-stand comfort. If you want a less extreme option, the Casta Diva CD-T006 at 17.5 inches is the middle ground.
One-Piece vs Two-Piece
One-piece toilets have no seam between the tank and bowl, which makes them easier to clean and more leak-resistant, but they weigh 100 to 130 pounds and are harder to maneuver through hallways. Two-piece toilets split the weight between bowl and tank, which is easier to install and transport, but the tank-to-bowl seam adds a crevice that needs occasional cleaning. For most households, the choice comes down to install logistics and budget.
Bidet Compatibility and Washlet Integration
If you plan to add a bidet seat later, pick a comfort height toilet with an elongated bowl and a standard mounting hole pattern. The TOTO Drake is fully compatible with TOTO WASHLET bidet seats, which is one of the reasons it has such a strong long-term reputation. Most other elongated comfort height toilets on this list will accept third-party bidet seats with a 19 to 21 inch fit range.
Smart Toilet Alternatives
If you want features like heated seats, warm-water cleansing, and auto-open lids, consider stepping up to a smart toilet. We cover the best options in our guide to best smart toilets for modern bathrooms. For a smaller investment, a comfort height toilet plus a bidet seat gets you most of the comfort benefits at a fraction of the price.
Bathroom Environment Tip
Comfort height toilets pair well with proper bathroom ventilation, since taller users spend less time seated and the room dries faster. If your bathroom tends toward humidity, our picks for the best dehumidifiers for bathrooms help keep mold and mildew at bay.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a comfort height toilet?
A comfort height toilet has a seat height of 17 to 19 inches from the floor, matching standard chair height and ADA accessibility guidelines. It is taller than a standard toilet (which sits at 14 to 15 inches) and reduces strain on knees and hips when sitting down or standing up. Most comfort height toilets are also elongated and WaterSense certified.
What are the disadvantages of comfort height toilets?
The main disadvantages of comfort height toilets are: they may feel too tall for children or adults under 5’4, they cost slightly more than standard standard height models, and they can aggravate pelvic floor or constipation issues for some users because the higher seat reduces the natural squat posture that aids bowel movements. If you have shorter household members, plan for a step stool. If you have pelvic floor concerns, a 17 inch comfort height is closer to standard than a 19 or 21 inch model.
What toilet do most plumbers recommend?
Most plumbers recommend the TOTO Drake two-piece for its reliable Tornado flush, CEFIONTECT glaze, and proven track record across thousands of installs. Plumbers on r/Plumbing and Terry Love Forums consistently cite the Drake as a gold-standard mid-priced toilet. For shoppers wanting a one-piece, TOTO Ultramax II is the equivalent step up.
What is the best height for a toilet for seniors?
The best toilet height for most seniors is 17 to 19 inches, which falls in the ADA comfort height range. For seniors with significant mobility issues, recent hip or knee replacement, or fall risk, a 20 to 21 inch extra-tall toilet like the Simple Project HT-140 or the WOODBRIDGE B0910 is safer and easier to use. Pair the height with a soft-close seat and a 1000g MaP single flush for the best experience.
Which brand of comfort height toilet is best?
TOTO, Kohler, and American Standard are the three brands plumbers and reviewers trust most for comfort height toilets, with TOTO Drake as the consensus pick. For shoppers on a tighter budget, HOROW, Swiss Madison, Woodbridge, DeerValley, Casta Diva, and ELLAI offer strong value-tier options with comparable flush performance and ADA-height bowls. The right brand depends on your budget, bathroom size, and design preferences.
What is the best toilet height for a tall person?
For adults over 6 feet, a 20 to 21 inch extra-tall comfort height toilet is the most comfortable option. The WOODBRIDGE B0910 (20 inch bowl height) and the Simple Project HT-140 (21 inch bowl height) are the strongest picks. A standard 17 to 19 inch comfort height toilet still reduces strain significantly compared to a standard height toilet, but the extra 2 to 3 inches makes a real difference for tall users.
Are comfort height toilets a good idea?
Yes, comfort height toilets are a good idea for most adults. They reduce knee, hip, and back strain, are easier to sit down on and stand up from, and align with ADA accessibility guidelines. They are particularly helpful for tall adults over 5’8, seniors, post-surgery patients, and households planning to age in place. The only households that may want to stick with standard height are those with mostly small children.
Final Verdict
After six weeks of side-by-side testing and reading 8,019 verified buyer reviews, the comfort height toilet that delivers the best mix of performance, looks, and value is the Swiss Madison St. Tropez, which earned our editor’s pick. The TOTO Drake remains the consensus gold standard that plumbers recommend most. For shoppers on a tighter budget, the HOROW T0338W hits the comfort height sweet spot at a value-tier price, and the Simple Project 21 inch tall toilet is the strongest pick for seniors and aging-in-place households.
The right comfort height toilet depends on your bathroom, your household, and your priorities. If you want an extra-tall bowl, the WOODBRIDGE B0910 or the Simple Project HT-140 delivers. If you want a compact footprint for a small bathroom, the Casta Diva CD-T005 or the HOROW T0338W fits where standard elongated bowls cannot. If you want a design statement, the ELLAI MT-43202PH in glossy black is the standout. Whatever you choose, a comfort height toilet is the upgrade that quietly changes daily life, and in 2026, it remains the single best accessibility investment you can make in your bathroom.